Actors In Video Marketing - Are they worth the money?

Wooden script reads leave video marketing dead on arrival. But authenticity is worth its weight in gold. Here's your guide to knowing when to cast Mark from accounts — and when to bring in a professional.

There is a version of a corporate video that haunts every marketer's nightmares. You know the one. An earnest but visibly terrified middle manager, frozen under a ring light, reading the company's value proposition off a piece of paper. Three. Syllables. At. A. Time. No one converted. No one called. No one did anything except quietly feel a bit embarrassed on the company's behalf. Here's the thing though — the fault isn't with the middle manager. It's with whoever handed them a script.

If You Need a Script, Hire an Actor. Full Stop.

Professional actors spend years — sometimes entire careers — learning one thing above all else: how to make a script sound like they just thought of it. That skill is genuinely, deceptively difficult. And the absence of it is immediately obvious on screen.

When you hand a script to someone who hasn't trained to deliver one, a predictable set of things happen. They stop listening to themselves and start thinking about the next line. Their eye contact goes strange. Their delivery becomes robotic. And the interview — which you'd budgeted an hour for — stretches to a half day ordeal as you coax take after take out of someone who is slowly, quietly, dying inside. Then you get to the edit. And you've got nothing. Because most of the takes are unusable.

If your video requires precise scripted language — specific product claims, carefully worded messaging, comedy that only works if it lands exactly right — then the answer is straightforward: hire a professional actor.

They'll learn their lines. They'll take direction. They'll give you ten usable takes in the time it takes your Head of Sales to get through one acceptable one. And crucially, they'll give you options in the edit — different reads, different energies, different emphasis — which is often where a video is won or lost. Yes, they cost more. Sometimes considerably more, depending on the role and usage. But weighed against a full day's shoot that produces nothing you can use, they're worth every penny.

But Don't Write Off Your Own People.

Here's the flip side, and it's an important one.

For a lot of video formats, a professional actor is entirely the wrong call. Testimonials. About Us films. Founder stories. Behind-the-scenes content. In every one of these, authenticity is the whole point.

And authenticity is something that even a very skilled actor will struggle to manufacture when the audience is actively looking for the real thing. When a real customer talks about your product, there's a texture to it — genuine pauses, slightly imperfect phrasing, the moment where their eyes light up because they actually mean what they're saying — that few performers can replicate convincingly. Viewers feel it. They trust it. And trust is ultimately what you're trying to build.

Your own staff and founders also bring something an actor simply can't: they actually know your business. They know the product inside out, they know why it matters, and they care about it. That knowledge — and the passion that comes with it — has a way of coming through on camera when you capture it the right way.

So no, Mark from accounts isn't a lost cause. He just needs handling correctly.

The Interview Technique — How to Get the Best Out of Real People.

The single worst thing you can do with a non-actor is hand them a script and ask them to learn and deliver it. It can be quite painful to behold.

Instead, your best bet is an interview... and done properly, it's one of the most powerful tools in video production. The principle is simple. Instead of asking someone to recite prepared lines, you ask them questions (I'd even discourage handing them a list of questions ahead of an interview, as they'll inevitably try and memorise a response, which amounts to the same problem.)

Conversational, well-planned questions that naturally draw out the information you need, in their own words, at their own pace. No memorisation. No pressure. Just a chat — a very well-directed chat can yield amazing results.

Shot on multiple cameras simultaneously, this gives you angle changes that let you cut between takes invisibly, skip over stumbles, and cherry-pick the best version of any given idea from across the whole conversation. Layer that with well-planned B-roll footage and you can cover almost any edit point without the audience ever noticing the joins.

What you end up with is a video that feels completely natural — because it is — but that tells exactly the story you need it to tell, assembled from the strongest material you captured. It's controlled, it's authentic, and it almost always connects better with an audience than a scripted equivalent.

A Word From Someone Who's Sat in Both Chairs.

Besides filmmaking, I've now spent over a decade also working as a professional actor including my ongoing run on The Archers on BBC Radio 4. So I know what it actually feels like to be on the other side of the camera/microphone. The nerves. The self-consciousness. The way a director's energy in the room either opens you up or shuts you straight down.

When it comes to interviewing people, especially those who have little to no penchant for performing, my personal experience in their shoes allows me to approach the whole idea from a position of understanding and empathy. I can spot if my subject is getting anxious or worried, feeling overwhelmed or confused and nip those feelings in the bud with a joke or just aknowleging how they feel, waiting until they settle back down before mining for more good stuff.

Getting a non-actor to relax, open up, feel comfortable and let their genuine personality come through isn't something you can force or rush. It takes patience, the right questions, and a quiet kind of directing that the subject ideally never realises is happening. Often its just about leeting them speak, not butting in too soon, giving them time to think about an answer and reply in their own time.

When it's done well, it really does work — you get something often with a depth that no scripted performance could have produced. A real person with a twinkle in their eye talking about something they genuinely care about and know about, in a way that connects with whoever is watching. That's the stuff worth chasing.

So — Actor or Real Person? Here's the Short Version.

Hire a professional actor when:

• Your video requires precise scripted language

• You're producing a TV commercial or high-impact online ad

• The role demands performance, character or comedy timing

• You're on a tight schedule and need someone who'll nail it fast

Use your own people when:

• You're making a testimonial, About Us or founder story

• Authenticity matters more than polish

• The subject has genuine passion and product knowledge to communicate

• Budget is a factor — interviews are typically far more cost-efficient to shoot Whatever you do — do not give a script to someone who hasn't trained to deliver one.

Not sure which approach your project needs? Give us a call — we'll give you a straight answer, no obligation.

Contact us